Swimming or drowning in the data ocean? Thoughts on the metaphors of big data

English: Tsunami hazard sign

English: Tsunami hazard sign (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

There is no doubt that there is a current fascination in both popular culture and academic research with big data – the vast quantities of data that are generated from people’s interactions with digital technologies. The term ‘big data’ is appearing with ever-greater frequency in the popular media, government reports, blogs and academic journals and conferences.

The ways in which big digital data are described rhetorically reveal much about their contemporary social and cultural meanings. As Sue Thomas writes in her book Technobiophilia: Nature and Cyberspace, organic metaphors drawn from the natural world have been continually used to describe computer technologies since their emergence. Such natural terms as the web, the cloud, bug, virus, root, mouse and spider have all been employed in attempting to conceptualise and describe these technologies. These metaphors work to render digital technologies more ‘natural’, and therefore as less threatening and alienating. However nature is not always benign: it may sometimes be wild, chaotic and threatening, and these meanings of nature may also be bestowed upon digital technologies.

By far the most commonly employed metaphors to discuss big data are those related to water or liquidity: streams, flows, leaks, rivers, oceans, seas, waves and so on. Both academic and popular cultural descriptions of big data have frequently referred to the ‘fire hose’ of data issuing from a social media site such as Twitter and the data ‘deluge’, ‘flood’ or ‘tsunami’ that as internet users we both contribute to and which threaten to ‘swamp’ or ‘drown us’. These rather vivid descriptions of data as a fluid, uncontrollable entity possessing great physical power emphasise the sheer volume and fast nature of digital data movements, as well as their unpredictability and the difficulty of control and containment. They suggest an economy of digital data and surveillance in which data are collected constantly and move from site to site in ways that cannot easily themselves be monitored, measured or regulated.

Other metaphors are sometimes employed to describe the by-product data that are generated include data ‘trails’, ‘breadcrumbs’, ‘exhausts’, ‘smoke signals’, ‘shadows’. All these tend to suggest the notion of data as objects that are left behind as tiny elements of another activity or entity (‘trails’, ‘breadcrumbs’, ‘exhausts’), or as less material derivatives of the phenomena from which they are viewed to originate (‘smoke signals’, ‘shadows’).

Digital data are also often referred as living things, as having a kind of vitality in their ability to move from site to site and morph into different forms. The rhizome metaphor is sometimes employed to describe how digital data flow from place to place, or from node to node, suggesting that they are part of a living organism such as a plant. This also suggests a high level of complexity and a network of interconnected tubes and nodes.

The focus on liquidity, ceaseless movement and flux and vitality, while accurately articulating the networked nature of contemporary societies and the speed and ease at which information travels across the networks, also tends to obscure certain dimensions of digitisation. The blockages and resistances, the solidities that may impede the fluid circulation of data tend to be left out of such discussions. The rhetoric of free streams of flowing communication tends to obscure the politics and power relations behind digital and other information technologies. The continuing social disadvantage and lack of access to economic resources (including the latest digital devices and data download facilities) that many people experience belies the discourse of free-flowing digital data and universal, globalised access to and sharing of these data.

Liquidity metaphors evoke the notion of an overwhelming volume of data that must somehow be dealt with, managed and turned to good use. Instead of ‘surfing the net’, a term that was once frequently used to denote moving from website to website easily and playfully, we now must cope with huge waves of information or data that threaten to engulf us. When we think of digital data as ‘breadcrumbs’ or ‘shadows’, they are less overtly threatening, but are also depicted as subtle means of tracking and tracing our movements and activities. As we grow increasingly aware of the use of digital data for surveillance and espionage purposes, these metaphors may take on a more malign meaning, suggesting that we are being monitored constantly whether we agree or not. Digital data surveillance systems are beginning to know more about us than we ourselves do in their capacity to silently watch and record our actions. When we conceptualise digital data and the systems that produce them as complex living organisms, they appear more benign, part of ‘good nature’, but also again as potentially wild and uncontained, growing out of our control.

What the rhetoric of big data tends to suggest is that we harbour both attraction towards and fear about this phenomenon. Big data may offer many benefits, but they also generate anxieties due to their volume, power, ceaseless movement, complexity, mystery and ability to generate knowledge about us that we may not want others to see.

For more on the social and cultural aspects of big data see my Bundlr ‘The Social Life of Big Data and Algorithms’.

21 thoughts on “Swimming or drowning in the data ocean? Thoughts on the metaphors of big data

  1. I’ve been writing about metaphor myself recently, Deborah. I’ve got a very tiny snippet of it in my just-out piece on influenza (see http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277953613005595). There’s more to come.

    It’s amazing, however, the extent to which metaphor shapes our experience of, well, technology, disease, food, bodies, anything, really! What this has brought to the fore in my thinking is the extent to which the humanities bring rich texture to both our social and our sociological worlds. I am glad you are thinking this way too.

    Do check out my Facebook page (https://www.facebook.com/DiagnosisInContemporarySociety). I love it if you liked me!

    • Thanks Annemarie, will have a look. I wrote a lot about the metaphors of HIV/AIDS back in the 1990s, and also about the computer virus metaphor, illness metaphors etc. As you say, fascinating stuff and an important way of conceptualising the world.

      • Well, I wrote quite a bit about metaphors of illness in my book Medicine As Culture. The computer virus article (‘Panic computing: the viral metaphor and computer technology’) was published in Cultural Studies in 1994 (yep, been writing about digital cultures for almost twenty years!).

        I haven’t seen the Genre issue – will check it out.

  2. Pingback: Watery Metaphors: Swimming or drowning in the data ocean #technobiophilia | Sue Thomas

  3. Pingback: Swimming or drowning in the data ocean? Thought...

  4. Pingback: The metaphors of big data | Thinking culture

  5. Pingback: Metáforas | COM 364

  6. Pingback: Impact of Social Sciences – The aesthetic elements of data visualisaton may offer a solution to the anxieties of big data.

  7. Pingback: Metaphors of Big Data | Re/code

  8. Pingback: CTSP | Data Science and Expanding Our Sources of Ethical Inspiration

  9. Pingback: Purity and Data - EPIC

  10. Pingback: Data Is the New What? Popular Metaphors & Professional Ethics in Emerging Data Culture « CA: Journal of Cultural Analytics

  11. Pingback: The language we use to describe data can also help us fix its problems – 121 News

  12. Pingback: Language we use – Two Kinds of Intelligence

  13. Pingback: Metaphors of data – it’s time to redefine how we talk about data – new ways of understanding digital data

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s